When the Appraisal Comes in Low, Experience Matters
The Situation
Our buyers were under contract on a home for $797,000, with a negotiated $22,000 seller credit toward closing costs.
Then the appraisal came back at just $750,000 — $47,000 below the agreed-upon purchase price.
A low appraisal can create a significant obstacle in a real estate transaction, potentially requiring buyers to bring additional funds to closing, renegotiate the purchase price, or reconsider the purchase altogether.
But we knew this wasn't necessarily the end of the conversation.
The Team Territo Strategy
We took a closer look at the appraisal and identified concerns with several of the comparable properties used to determine the home's value.
Some were located outside the property's ZIP code, one was a distressed property, and another was in a gated community.
These differences raised questions about how accurately the comparable sales reflected the home our buyers were purchasing.
Knowing the local market and understanding which properties are truly comparable can make all the difference.
Rather than simply accepting the initial valuation, we challenged the appraisal and pursued a reconsideration of value.
The revised appraisal came back at $775,000 — an increase of $25,000.
With that information, we returned to the negotiating table, focused on finding a solution that worked for both parties.
The Result
Our buyers loved the home, the sellers were motivated to move forward, and we successfully negotiated revised terms.
THE FINAL PURCHASE PRICE WAS REDUCED BY $22,000, AND OUR BUYERS STILL RECEIVED AN $11,000 SELLER CREDIT.
| Transaction Details | Amount |
|---|---|
| Original contract price | $797,000 |
| Initial appraisal | $750,000 |
| Revised appraisal | $775,000 |
| Final purchase price | $775,000 |
| Seller credit at closing | $11,000 |
The buyers secured the home they wanted at a lower purchase price while retaining a meaningful closing cost credit.
Why Representation Mattered
An appraisal is an important part of the homebuying process, but a low valuation doesn't always mean the transaction has to fall apart.
This is why local market knowledge, experience, and negotiation skills matter for both buyers and sellers.
A knowledgeable Realtor understands how to evaluate comparable sales, recognize potential discrepancies, navigate appraisal challenges, and advocate for their customer's best interests.
In this case, taking the time to question the valuation and negotiate new terms helped turn a potentially difficult situation into a successful outcome.
A LOW APPRAISAL DOESN'T HAVE TO MEAN A LOST OPPORTUNITY.
Real estate is about more than finding a home and writing an offer. It's about knowing how to navigate the unexpected and having the experience to find solutions when challenges arise.
That's the value of having Team Territo in your corner.